PulpExposure wrote:ATX_Skins wrote:PulpExposure wrote:ATX_Skins wrote:I don't want a switch. We are 3-1 with Rex. He makes some boneheaded errors but thats what happens when you throw for almost 300.
He had some horrible errors today and threw for...143. Far cry from 300...
Yeah, my bad, I just checked the stats.
Regardless of how bad he played, I don't think the logical choice it to make a QB switch right now.
didn't we know what we were getting with him. He has ALWAYS had bad throws. If he played flawless people would still find a reason to want a switch.
Beck is on the bench for a reason, and the reason is because he is not as good as Grossman.
I guess. I just can't really think that he'd really be any worse. Grossman was horrific today. He had a 48.5 passer rating. More troubling was that you just cannot trust him, at all, to make a throw when needed. If that's the case, how could Beck (or heck, anyone) be a worse choice?
Rex is a limited QB -
no arm - you can't call certain plays and expect to be successful.
No mobility - you can't call your staple boot as much as you want to. Once Rex is trapped, he
can't make plays with his feet. He often
doesn't read the linebacker (how many times have you heard Rex say, I didn't see the linebacker?). He makes
poor decisions at least one or two a game. The defense has played very well the last two games, but the O has failed to do it's part and score the points.
Do you really change QBs when your team has a winning record? No coach would so such a thing!!! No coach! Period! Whaaat? Hold it a second.... I am wrong - some coach named
Mike Shanahan did it in Denver - pulling Jake Plummer, a QB he liked for Jay Cutler, a QB he coveted. He likes Grossman. He covets Beck.
Maybe now is not the time, but Rex is Rex. The handwriting is on the wall. Take away the Moss tip ball and you still have an O that doesn't move except for when Torain came in and saved the day.
With Rex, this team is
going nowhere. We will win more ugly games like this one. Will will lose more ugly games like last week. If the defense scores and we get the opposition to do boneheaded personal fouls we will win games like we did against the Giants. Rex is streaky and can play like an All-pro at times, but with him at the helm. Where is this team going?
For Shanny, the question is,
when is the right time to do it. My guess is
Rex starts against Philly and if we are listless on O - to spark the team, Beck will come off the bench. Rex's days this season are numbered.
Why Beck? His upside, compared to Grossman is too good. He has an arm. He has the mobility. He is susceptible to mistakes, but that is because of lack of experience - chances are he will grow. We know Rex won't grow.