Okay, so first I spar with Fios taking a negative view point, and now I'll defend the Skins against HS's attack here:
smoot the first time.
No way. Smoot wanted big money and he got it. He played for the Vikings like other FA's play for us. The Skins played Smoot perfectly—letting him go when it was going to be too costly to keep him, taking him back at a discount when he was hungry again. And he's playing beautifully for us.
And, my memory isn't that short. I remember the way many THN members chose to remember Smoot's first tenure here in D.C.

carlos isn't exactly a game breaker. couldn't catch a cold.
I disagree and I think we've seen just how much we miss Carlos after he went out this year. He has been improving and, dare I say, was
good this year.

It's time to stop living in 2005; Rogers is showing himself to be the real deal.
walt harris. not great, but played within the system. and did it well.
No, we should have cut Harris based on his play for us. Our secondary needed help, and he wasn't it. In fact, Garnell Wilds seemed to have more promise, IMO (especially since he's 7 years younger than Harris).
But I must admit that Harris' breakout in SF astonishes me to this day.
clark, we wouldn't have even had to endure the AA debacle with a starter entrenched. guy wasn't even asking a third of what arch wanted.
antonio pierce. homegrown talent. not a ray lewis, but we wouldn't have had to go after fletcher, not that he is all bad, but with all that cap space, we could be a bit less laughable as far as depth. and that brings up the next point.
Agreed. . .
depth. we have NONE. betts backing portis may be the strongest depth on the team.
I think we're seeing some decent depth on the O-line and in our secondary. Our d-line has no all-stars but 6 of our guys seem capable of playing at the same level (does that count?).
Overall I agree with you on depth, though, and I think our FA strategy has contributed greatly to that.
Really, the only players I agree with you on are Clark and Pierce. I'm glad that we cut everyone else you mentioned—and don't forget the other players Gibbs let go: Rod Garnder, Coles, Dockery (7 years 49 million, anyone?). . .again, aside from Clark and Pierce I think we've done a
good job of letting players go at the right time.
You also have to include timely signings / extensions, which now include players like Jon Jansen, Chris Samuels, Chris

ey, and Ladell Betts.
In sum, I think things aren't quite as one sided as the evil lord has chosen to phrase them.