Lemar Marhall vs. Antonio Pierce

[frankcal20]

I think this should be title....If Antonio Pierce wasn't hurt right now who would rather have. I would prefer Antonio but I would prefer both.

[John Manfreda]

I didn't vote because I think there the same.

[redskindave]

Lemar Marshall hands down

[John Manfreda]

I voted for Lemar just because I found out Pierce was hurt and durability is part of the game.

[SkinsHead56]

I am not convinced that Pierce is even better than Lemar. This was Lemar's first year as a MLB and I think he will improve, he has filled in well, and his contract is much more affordable. Pierce is injured right now too.

Lemar seems like a good team player who we don't have to re-sign for mega-millions. Good decision to let Pierce hit the market.

I take AP. This would have been his second year in the GW Defense. He owned this D last year. Imagine what he could have done this year. Remember it was AP's first year in a move from will to mike LB. He was just awesome.
I also think Lemar has done a great job with his chance this year hopefully he can continue to develop into a very good player, if not he'll be fighting off McCune very soon.

[UK Skins Fan]

Right now, I think Pierce is the better linebacker. But then he did come out with the usual "I want to be a Redskin, I will be a Redskin next year, it would have to be a break the bank kind of offer for me to leave next year, the ball is in the Redskins' court, the Redskins don't want to pay me, the Redskins are lowballing me, Dan Snyder didn't want to keep me, those guys didn't respect me, I'm really excited about being a Giant" garbage.

I'm sick of hearing this crap from free agents year after year, and I include the ones who sign for the Redskins.

So, to answer the question, Pierce is a better linebacker at the moment, but I'd rather have Lemar right now, because I think he has more potential, and because he hasn't yet pee'd me off with the "I want my money" trash that they all come out with sooner or later. Boy, do I sound bitter?

[John Manfreda]

Is Pierce out for the Redskins game this week. I don't know the extent of his injury.

[1niksder]

Is Pierce out for the Redskins game this week. I don't know the extent of his injury.

Done for the year...

[DESkins]

I'll take Marshall. He wants to be here, and more importantly, he IS here. Good luck to Pierce, but he ain't here and he ain't a Redskin.

[(d)oink]

I'll take Marshall. He wants to be here, and more importantly, he IS here. Good luck to Pierce, but he ain't here and he ain't a Redskin.

'nuff said. Marshall here. Pierce has moved on. See ya Antonio.

[Hoss]

hands down, marshall is better right now.

[JansenFan]

Right now, I'd take Marshall because AP is injured.

[HitDoctor]

This is ridiculous! Pierce is the better player. He wanted to be here, but the skins didn't want to pay. It is what it is. I root for the laundry.

[JansenFan]

This is ridiculous! Pierce is the better player. He wanted to be here, but the skins didn't want to pay. It is what it is. I root for the laundry.

Amen. Idon't like AP anymore cause he wouldn't take less money to stay, but I would probably follow the money as well. That doesn't diminish his ability.

[Smithian]

Antonio Pierce was the better linebacker, but Lemar Marshall has yet to leave and bad mouth the team, so I would rather have Marshall.

[thaiphoon]

Lemar - hands down !!

The reason is I think he has more upside and gives us a dimension we didn't get with Pierce.

Also his INT was huge today...

But the main reason is that he is here and Pierce is not.

[redskinsranger]

As you can see by the Avatar, of COURSE I CHOOSE LEMAR!!!

[redskincity]

Antonio fights through his blocks better than Marshall. He is a much better MLB right now. Marshall will improve mentaly in due time.

INMO I think that Marshall should hit the weights this offseason. He is around 230 and that's too light for a Mike.

[Chris Luva Luva]

Antonio fights through his blocks better than Marshall. He is a much better MLB right now. Marshall will improve mentaly in due time.

INMO I think that Marshall should hit the weights this offseason. He is around 230 and that's too light for a Mike.

Man! Where have you been hiding out at?

[redskincity]

Antonio fights through his blocks better than Marshall. He is a much better MLB right now. Marshall will improve mentaly in due time.

INMO I think that Marshall should hit the weights this offseason. He is around 230 and that's too light for a Mike.

Man! Where have you been hiding out at?

Man I have been too busy. I havent had time much and lately I have been hanging out at the site below attempting to score an Xbox 360. These site send instant emails to your account.

http://www.tagscan.com/xbox-360-stockwatch.html

http://www.gamermill.com/home.php

[fredp45]

I voted for Marshall not because I think he's a better player than Pierce but because I'd rather have him, everything considered. I think the Giants overpaid for a good (not dominant) MLB. MLB is a position that I think you can save some money on.

I think the Redskins liked and wanted to keep Pierce (& Smoot) but they decided that they weren't worth the cap hit. Our cap was already busting through with the $9 mil Coles trade.

Marshall is a good player for our defense and he's very affordable.

[washington53]

Considering that we turned Marshall to inside in a matter of months, we has come a long way and he has helped us in tackling, calling audibles in the defense, and intercepting passes.... id take him over Pierce.

[Chris Luva Luva]

Antonio fights through his blocks better than Marshall. He is a much better MLB right now. Marshall will improve mentaly in due time.

INMO I think that Marshall should hit the weights this offseason. He is around 230 and that's too light for a Mike.

Man! Where have you been hiding out at?

Man I have been too busy. I havent had time much and lately I have been hanging out at the site below attempting to score an Xbox 360. These site send instant emails to your account.

http://www.tagscan.com/xbox-360-stockwatch.html

http://www.gamermill.com/home.php

Well hurry up and get one. I need more decent people on my friends list before all the 12 year old racist kids get them.

[WshSkins22]

ummmm, is there still a controversy about this...

We are losing 20-17, playoffs are on the line. Eagles are driving, and this so-called " replacement" comes up witht the cluth interception which leads to a touchdown. This guy two weeks in a row has made an interception which helps win the game. I think he leads our team in int's also, as a MLB. This just further proves that we made a smart move when letting go pierce. CLL makes some good points though, im not going to lie

[Chris Luva Luva]

ummmm, is there still a controversy about this...

We are losing 20-17, playoffs are on the line. Eagles are driving, and this so-called " replacement" comes up witht the cluth interception which leads to a touchdown. This guy two weeks in a row has made an interception which helps win the game. I think he leads our team in int's also, as a MLB. This just further proves that we made a smart move when letting go pierce. CLL makes some good points though, im not going to lie

Well I did say I felt Lemar was better in coverage than AP. I still feel that AP is the better LB at this point. I think with maturity, and some dominant linemen to keep bodies off of him Lemars game could escalate even further. I know it will.