The-Hogs.net - Washington Football Discussion, Redskins to Commanders Era

riggofan wrote:

frankcal20 wrote:

SkinsJock wrote::shock: Why would a team, like the Redskins, give up draft picks for a player when there are better players available

Plaxico Burress is a better WR than Josh Gordon

I heard the same thing yesterday on SiriusXM NFL Radio yesterday. Said why take a flyer when you can get a proven product who can get you 9-11 TDs this year. Plax will be an option for any team who has a training camp injury and is a contender for the playoffs. Mark my words.

I get the argument, but seems like kind of a moot point. Spending a draft pick on Josh Gordon doesn't prevent the Skins from signing Plaxico Burress if they wanted to, does it?

I don't really see what Plax has to do with the decision. You could kind of say the same thing about any of the Skins current WRs. Why keep Anthony Armstrong/Brandon Banks/Terrence Austin around when Plax can get you 9-11 TDs this year?

I don't think Banks or Austin make the team this year due to the guys we brought in. Banks would still be on the roster if the kickoff rules were like before but now, it limits his value.

It's really going to come down to how much to me the coaching staff likes the other guys and if they feel this guy can be an upgrade. Also, you have to consider what we're giving up in next years draft position wise. There's a lot that goes into this and you want to make sure you get it right. My biggest concern is if the guy cracks the lineup this year. I expect to see the following WR's playing in 2012:

1 - Garcon
2 - Hankerson
3 - Moss
4 - Morgan
5 - Armstong
6 - Robinson

These are the guys I think will make the squad. Due to the flexibility of Davis and his ability to line up wide, I don't forsee us keeping 7 WR's this year. I do think we'll have only 3 TE's

1. Davis
2. Cooley
3. Paul

In all honesty, I just don't think we're willing to assume the risk and get rid of guys the coaches have seen and spoke highly of. Of course guys like Armstrong & Robinson are on the ledge, I don't think, given our lack of draft picks in the coming years will allow us the luxury to spend a pick on a guy who hasn't played in a few seasons and mind you, just tweaked his hammy at his pro-day and has a history of making bad decisions.

But, with that being said, if the coaches feel its the best move for the team then I'm going to run with it b/c they have access to way more information than any of us. I would just hope we don't have to pay too much to get him. That way if it doesn't pan out, we aren't left with Egg on our face.

The point is this - the Redskins have other priories than giving up a draft pick for a WR who might become a good NFL WR

I don't like Plaxico Burress - IF a franchise was in dire need (IMHO we are NOT) why add this kid when you can add Burress and not give up picks

this kid might show that he's grown up but he's certainly shown that he can make bad choices

the Redskins are not taking a chance with this kid

frankcal20 wrote:Was just reported on SiriusXM NFL Radio that RG3 is pushing the Redskins to draft this kid. Who knows if it's legit or not but the rumor is out there and now being advertised.

Your right. It is out there. This report is coming from Jason La Canfora.

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/20 ... sh-gordon/

Below is an Hogshaven interview with RGIII concerning Gordon. Hogshaven has tweeted La Canfora to say that haven't reached the conclusion that he has from their interview with RGIII.

What are your thought's on Josh Gordon's Pro Day?

I think he's focused and ready to go at his Pro Day. I texted him yesterday and he didn't hit me back so that means he's getting ready to gear up and show his talents. I definitely wish the best for him.
(for some reason I had my daily brain fart at this very moment)

Do you plan to throw at his Pro Day? (as I try and reach my arm through my phone land line to pull my words back.)

Let me see. His Pro Day is today and I'm in L.A....so....
(The response 99% of America would have said in his shoes: "That's a clown question, bro?")

My bad. I got my dates mixed up there. How do you think he'll translate to the NFL given his short amount of film and the issues he's had?

I mean, it's up to him. Whether he wants to make it or not. I can't say whether he's going to be successful or not be successful. It's just to him and what he wants to do to leave his legacy.

http://www.hogshaven.com/2012/7/10/3148 ... #storyjump

this is amazing

why does anyone think the Redskins are giving up a draft pick for this kid

there are other areas of concern here AND there are enough guys trying out for the 6 or 7 slots already - I don't see the point

RG3 came out and said he is NOT advocating for the Redskins to sign this guy.

frankcal20 wrote:It's really going to come down to how much to me the coaching staff likes the other guys and if they feel this guy can be an upgrade. Also, you have to consider what we're giving up in next years draft position wise. There's a lot that goes into this and you want to make sure you get it right.

Well thought out post. I completely agree. Will be interesting to see what happens today.

SkinsJock wrote:this is amazing

why does anyone think the Redskins are giving up a draft pick for this kid

there are other areas of concern here AND there are enough guys trying out for the 6 or 7 slots already - I don't see the point

I have no idea if the Redskins will give up a pick for this kid. Its just been in the football news this week, so people are discussing it. Honestly, it seems like most people posting on here would be surprised if the Skins did make a move, given their draft pick situation.

Just curious, SkinsJock, if we're talking about a 4th or 5th round pick next year (and assuming the coaching staff thinks Gordon is worth that), what areas on the team would you use that pick for ahead of a WR? Probably corner/safety? I would agree, just not sure how much of an upgrade you can expect there with a 4/5 pick.

It remains to be seen how Garcon, Morgan and Hankerson do this year. Moss isn't getting any younger. Personally, I still see WR as a weakness on the team.

Well if they do get him that would tell us what think about the WR that are on the team.....

Just went to the Browns with a 2nd round pick. Would say that he's a good fit there as they have a HUGE need for WR.

2d round pick! Wow. I think the Browns just decided there was no way they were letting the Skins beat them to another player.

Per twitter and multiple people, the Browns were the only team to bring him in for a visit and more importantly, he was there for a few days.

Also, Rich Gannon brings up a good point. Brad Childress is now on the coaching staff on offense and he loves young WR's.

So the Browns get Gordon and give up a 2nd round pick next season, is that right...?



Errr, wouldn't they have been more likely to get RG3 if they had been prepared to give up that 2nd round pick...???

Oh dear....

SouthLondonRedskin wrote:So the Browns get Gordon and give up a 2nd round pick next season, is that right...?



Errr, wouldn't they have been more likely to get RG3 if they had been prepared to give up that 2nd round pick...???

Oh dear....

Karmic juistice

a 2nd round pick - and that pick might very well be the 35th to 38th slot - that is AMAZING



I would agree that WR is a position of need with the Redskins but ....
this franchise has already made some moves and we really don't know how the other guys will be with RGIII

IMHO - the WR position is going to be filled from the group that is here


with our draft pick situation, THANKFULLY we did not go after this guy

I just don't see giving up even a fifth pick for a kid that is going to take time to get ready to play and basically did not play at all in 2011

I'd like to know what other teams made offers, and what round they were willing to go. I guess they don't publish that info.

not much about this is clear, JSPB .....

The process involves 'bidding' - it's reported that Cleveland thought it might be as high as a 3rd round pick

they wanted this kid and offered a 2nd .....

IMHO - that is just a really bad decision

SkinsJock wrote:I would agree that WR is a position of need with the Redskins but ....
this franchise has already made some moves and we really don't know how the other guys will be with RGIII

IMHO - the WR position is going to be filled from the group that is here

Looks like you're right on that one! Let's hope the earlier WR moves pay off this season and we're stronger at the position than we thought.

Deadskins wrote:I'd like to know what other teams made offers, and what round they were willing to go. I guess they don't publish that info.

No one else put a 2nd round pick on Gordon, so far no release on who else put out bids. Schefty, the man who knows most all, may get some more info later.

Schefter also noted that the Browns were the only team to submit a second-round pick for Gordon. That means that a third-round pick would have likely landed him. But the Browns had to submit a claim based on what they thought Gordon was worth and what other teams might do.

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1256 ... ntal-draft