skinsfan#33 wrote:SkinsJock wrote:I'm still a big fan of this FO and what they've done ..
as far as Mike's job as HC - I'm waiting to hear about RG3's knee ....
What's RG3 knee got to do with Shanny's job as a HC?
I would say most NFL HCs would have done the exact same thing! I have know problem with a HC letting a player that says he is OK and the Drs clear him play in a game.
Chris Clemons didn't have a prior injury and still toe his ACL (w/o contact). Who knows, but RG3 could have injured his lee in that game even w/o it being injured prior.
You can disagree with him leaving RG3 in the game when it was clear he was ineffective and I would understand that, but judging his coaching job based on the outcome of his knee exam is very short sighted in my mind. To me one had nothing to do with the other!
I can understand the question - I am ONLY pointing to how things were handled by Mike since the play involving Ngata
Mike is ultimately responsible for everything that happened and as HC, in my opinion, he did not handle the issue with RG3's knee very well at all
I did not mean to imply that the ONLY thing that mattered was IF RG3 required surgery ...
I should have said that AFTER the visit to Dr Andrews - in my opinion, Mike needs to clear the air about how he 'managed' all this
I think he should but I doubt seriously that he will
It's all over now and we just have to hope that Mike, Dr Andrews and RG3, all learned a lot about this
HEY - I feel Mike should have done better at a lot of things regarding RG3 since he hurt the knee - that's just my opinion
I DO NOT think he should be let go but, he would, IN MY OPINION, be a better man if he tried to be straight with all of us about this
NOT GOING TO HAPPEN
