PulpExposure wrote:chiefhog44 wrote:Big supporter once? You make it sounds like that was eon's ago. What, your view has changed from two months ago? Talk about short sighted. Shannahan hasn't even been here for a full season. Ah whatever. I don't care to tell you the truth. If you don't support him anymore, that's fine by me. Let's get another coach in here this offseason, and blow it up again.
I guess I believe, as most football people do, that Shanny and Bruce are the right people and they need time. I guess I want this to work, because I think this may be the last stop for me, and I'm guessing for many other fans as well.
The time from when they were hired to now does seem like eons ago. My issue is that this team is not even competitive anymore. 2 of the past 3 games, the Skins have been absolutely torched by NFC East opponents. This team lacks talent throughout the roster; can you name a position that you would consider a position of strength (besides perhaps TE)?
More problematic, I'm not sure that's something that will be rectified. The Skins, as always, do not have a full draft next year to help rebuild. More damning, the evidence to date shows that the acquisitions that Shanahan and Allen have made are not positive. They've made trades that have robbed the team of important draft picks, yet have yielded very little in return. The free agent pickups they made were wastes of money and time. And the trades (for draft picks) and pickups show that Shanahan isn't interested in fixing this thing from the get-go; he wants to win, and win now (else why would you trade 2 very valuable picks for a 34 year old QB)?
And the talent we have isn't fitting in the systems that Shanahan has chosen to run. The 3-4 has been a disaster here; and on offense, it's not much better. The zone blocking system is the no-zone blocking system; the offensive line is giving up more sacks than last year, and the Redskins cannot muster even a mediocre running game. To me, one hallmark of a good coach is adaptability; when the talent doesn't fit the system, you fit the system to the talent. That's just not happening here.
I'm struggling to think of a positive; what evidence do you have that Shanahan is working out here at all? It's not like this team is getting better (as it did under Schottenheimer). It's getting worse. And it's not as if they're using this time to groom young players...as the Redskins essentially have none.
Please, tell me why I should remain optimistic about Shanahan, where to my eyes,
nothing he has done to date has worked out.
First off, I'm not asking you to remain positive about shannahan, just asking you and other unrealitic fans to be a bit more realistic about to state of afairs with this team. We suck. We sucked 11 months ago when you and others were thinking we were going to the playoffs and were optimistic. We don't have any talent nor depth. This is 17 years in the making that you are going to blame Shannahan for? Please. He had barely an offseason and all of a sudden we have a decent receiver in Armstrong, a LT in Williams, a probowl Qb in McNabb, and a killer returner BB. And we may have something with Torain, Williams, and Davis. No one could overhaul the entire roster in this short of a time. Add 4-5 guys like this a year, and there you have it. A 3-4 year turnaround.
The greatest thing that Shannahan has done this year is to hold players accountable. The best player plays...period.
I agree, with coaches who come into a good roster (like Tomlin did with the Steelers) you adjust your scheme to fit the players, but why would any coach want to fit a successful system with crap talent? It's still going to be crap. Why not take the opportunity to start implementing a successful scheme. You don't know how many draft picks we have yet for next year until after the draft takes place. There could be trades even on the day of.
If you want to argue about picking up Mcnabb, that's fine, but I'm not convinced that was a bad move yet. It's too soon to tell. But to say you used to be optimistic 11 months ago and now you are not, because our running game sucks for instance, well did you ever realize that this is like our 15th running back to date? Or about the passing game, we have a crap O-line, what do you expect? Or our defense, we are switching schemes and replacing that so called 5th ranked D. I hated that defense. We were DEAD last in turnovers with 17!!!! 17 f-ing turnovers. That is PATHETIC! Did you seriously think we were going to win even 8 games with this roster? That's your fault, not any coach.