Determing if McNabb Sucks Somewhat Scientifically

[fredp45]

Lots of facts about McNabb but the truth is -- we're 4-3 with virtually the same offense we had last year, which was the most horrible offense I've ever seen.

Here we are:

we've installed a new offense,
we don't have a #1 WR, in fact, we started a WR that was washed up 4 years ago and another guy who may end up (in a year or so) being a #2 in Armstrong,
we have backups at both guard positions,
we have a free agent RB, in fact, a guy WE cut before the year started,
a rookie LT, (who's been out with injuries)
a RT who is not only coming back from a year long injury but is learning a new position (LT-RT),
a Center that gets dominated by big DT's.

THANK GOD FOR MCNABB.

Some of you guys are as bad as Mike and Mike in the am, you take a stand just to hear yourself type..

All in all -- he is not our problem, find something else to complain about.

[tcwest10]

Donovan is like a decent golfer who has a streaky putter. He'll manage his game well enough to shoot a pretty good score, but when the putts start dropping he goes low.

Wasn't that the basic premise of "Happy Gilmore"?

[chiefhog44]

Hear is the most scientific way of knowing McNabb will have a HUGE game tomorrow.

The guy I am playing in fantasy football had Tony Romo and Matt Ryan. Romo gets his colar bone broken and Ryan is on a bye. So what does the guy I desperately need a win against do? He picks up McNabb and starts him.

I have never finished worse than 4th in FF and right now I'm dead last with 4 straight losses.

McNabb will have a MONSTER game tomorrow and I will lose my 5th straight! That is just how my luck runs!

You are describing my team to a T. Never missed the playoffs etc, but I'm in the fight of my life this year! Did you draft MJD as well???

[Bob 0119]

Statistically speaking, the 'Pukes have both a top-ten offense and defense...

...and they are 1-5.

[1niksder]

Statistically speaking, the 'Pukes have both a top-ten offense and defense...

...and they are 1-5.

They are who we thought they are

[Irn-Bru]

I'm just sick of blind homers.

I've been around this board a long time, and that is always the rallying cry over critics who don't enjoy being called out for weak arguments.

[die cowboys die]

i'm glad to see this thread up here, because i was going to start one asking for McNabb to be cut--- yes, that's right, not benched, cut. when you have a "leader" that doesn't even bother to show up and make any effort whatsoever for 2 straight weeks, you've got to send a message. this won't fly under the shanahan regime. cut him. he's been beyond excruciatingly atrocious the past couple games.

[Skinsfan55]

McNabb has been a complete waste of picks. At least Philly will probably only get our 4th rounder next season... then again, New Orleans will get our 3rd for Brown.

[Hoss]