BossHog wrote:What does that have to do with anything? Sure, doing the show with Brandon was great and we were appreciative, but do you see ANYTHING in my post that looks at all like it has to do with the play on the field, or even a personal opinion on Brandon?
We didn't do a show with Arch. We didn't do a show with Lavar. We didn't do a show with Coles. I don't feel any differently about their exits and the cap space they took with them... my post addressed nothing else.
Fair enough. Perhaps I should have made two posts to avoid the confusion. My 1st paragraph was in response to your post and how the dead cap issue is not exclusive to the Skins and doesn't always affect the final product, as in the Giants case. The last 3 paragraphs weren't directed at you but were merely an extension of my thoughts on the matter. Sorry, I understand where you're coming from.
As far as the end result of this, the dead cap money, as you clearly mentioned in your initial post, I absolutely agree with. It sucks and seems like such a waste. But other then for the end result, in no way shape or form would I compare what happened to Lloyd to what happened to LaVar and Arch.
I actually blame GW just as much for the LaVar and Arch situations. I believe it was GW that wanted to sign Arch and it was predominantly GW that drove LaVar out. The money aspect I do blame on the front office, which is what I believe you are referring to, so I agree. But I just see it as Snyder trying to facilitate what the coaches wanted.
But Lloyd is a much different issue. The mistake was signing him in the first place, not cutting him. I also read and heard the reports, one by Wilbon, that it was Gibbs that wanted to sign Lloyd and the front office warned him about character issues. I believe Gibbs thought he could break through with Lloyd. But never should a players bad behavior or lack of effort be rewarded just so his dead cap number is lessened. That would be condoning the behavior and an extremely poor example. They never should have signed him in the first place and that's where the mistake was made.
I understand and agree with you about overpaying and dead cap numbers from early releases. But in Lloyd's case, IMO, it's not the same. Lloyd brought this on himself and completely embarrassed Gibbs. But in no way, and let me be clear about this, is that "apologizing" for the organization. I have NEVER apologized on behalf of Snyder or the organization. Much like Arch, it was a bad investment, cut your losses, move on and hope they learn from their mistakes.