Need help on agruement about how Deion is overrated

[ejay183]

Some of my friends and I are agruing cause I said Deion is overrated. All my friends brings up is that he has alot of INTs. Help!

[Irn-Bru]

You could bring up his penchant for falling down rather than trying to tackle someone.


It's pretty obvious that I suck at Smack, so I'll let other people help you out.

[skinsRin]

He was never much of a tackler or hard hitter but I almost have to agree with your friends. In his prime he was so dangerous. In his years with the 9ers and the Cowboys he dominated on Defense and as a kick returner. So, I would say in his prime before the Skins signed him he was not overrated. Sorry man.

[redskingush]

Not overrated at all, I say underrated, he had closing speed in his prime, unbelievable.

[Primetime42]

Lock Deion on one side of the field, that receiver doesn't catch a pass all day long.

Unless it was Rice. Then he might have caught one or two

[skinpride1]

Back in the early 90's Sanders was the man!!!I think his best play was with the niner's!!!!(did ok for the boys)Then his age and greed caught up with him and got the skins burned for paying him a huge deal!!!Early 90's was great, after that just average!!!

[gay4pacman]

as a redskins he let up one touchdown pass

[Skinsfan55]

When Deion played baseball he wanted to meet Curt Schilling in the parking lot after a game to fight.

Schilling laughed at him and said he wasn't going to meet him at the flagpole after recess and that Deion was just a glorified flag football player.

FYI, Schilling is like 6-4 230 and was much younger at the time, that's the kind of fight where there only would have been 3 hits...

Schilling hitting Sanders, Sanders hitting the ground and the ambulance hitting 90 on the way to the hospital.

[welch]

Sanders could make interceptions, but he couldn't cover as well as Darrell Green. Stats don't tell the story. Teams didn't throw to the DG side -- note the year that Barry Wilburn led the league in INT's because everything went toward his man. Oh, and Green had terrible hands.

Sanders wouldn't tackle, which is fairly important when you're playing defense.

DG and Rod Woodson were better players.

[DarthMonk]

Some of my friends and I are agruing cause I said Deion is overrated. All my friends brings up is that he has alot of INTs. Help!

I think calling him "the best ever" is an over-rating. DG was every bit as good. DG was faster, a better tackler, and every bit as dangerous returning punts. DS was good. DS was great. DS was not the "best cover corner ever."

Now this will sound like crying but much like Michael Irvin, DS got away with more than most. I don't know how many times I saw DG get called for ticky tack nothing (ironic seeing as how he was such a good guy) while DS would often get away with murder. Ever notice how Madden and Summerall were always saying Troy, Michael, Emmit, and Deion but were never saying Doug, Art, John, and Darrell? It was always Williams, Monk, Riggins, and Green - as it should be.

Darth

[Chris Luva Luva]

Darrell Greens shortcoming which is one of my own is that he isn't that tall.

Its an amazing feat that he was the beast he was at his height.

[welch]

Darrell Greens shortcoming which is one of my own is that he isn't that tall.

Green wasn't tall, but he could jump. Something Gibbs and Petibon always mentioned: when Green and a WR jumped for a ball, Green was likely to be just as high.

Consider, also, that the difference in height -- maybe six inches -- between Green and a tall WR comes to very little when a QB is trying to hit a running receiver at 20 or 30 yards distance.

Green? The best CB of his time.

Sanders? Overblown.

*

Oh...in addition to the Curt S. story, there was the "Pudge" faceoff, when Fisk was catching for the White Sox, and Sanders didn't bother to run out a ground ball. Fisk said something like, "You embarass your team when you do that". Sanders challenged Pudge, who threatened to pound Sanders into the ground like a tent peg. Significant thing: not a single Yankee came off the bench to back Sanders. They were thinking the same thing as Fisk.

[Hogfather]

Back in the early 90's Sanders was the man!!!I think his best play was with the niner's!!!!(did ok for the boys)Then his age and greed caught up with him and got the skins burned for paying him a huge deal!!!Early 90's was great, after that just average!!!

I would have to say his best play was in Atlanta. That's when he became PRIMETIME.

[skinsRin]

However you look at it Primetime was a dominate player, every team was afraid of him. The only thing he wasn't great at was tackeling but evey other part of his game was A+.

[gay4pacman]

However you look at it Primetime was a dominate player, every team was afraid of him. The only thing he wasn't great at was tackeling but evey other part of his game was A+.

agree

[Redskins Rule]

Didn't Primetime get hit in the head with a ball or something? Wasn't it on a punt return and instead of catching it it just bounced off of his head?

Thats what I heard anyway. I really want to know if it happened or not.

[Primetime42]

My lasting memory was his last game vs. you with us when he blew up Stephen Davis.

...and then got a concussion later in the game.

[Chris Luva Luva]

My lasting memory was his last game vs. you with us when he blew up Stephen Davis.

...and then got a concussion later in the game.

Had he been saving that one tackle for a long time? I guess two tackles in a game exceeded his quota.

[Primetime42]

My lasting memory was his last game vs. you with us when he blew up Stephen Davis.

...and then got a concussion later in the game.

Had he been saving that one tackle for a long time? I guess two tackles in a game exceeded his quota.

What I never understood is why. He use to lay people out at FSU. I remember vividly going "OOOOOH" when he would.

Was it the persona? Or did he just start believing his own hype?