The-Hogs.net - Washington Football Discussion, Redskins to Commanders Era

who does your vote go to? i have to say mine goes to mcnair. he's a little dinged up right now, but for some reason, always plays better when he's hurt. i like peyton, but he's just not playin up to par right now.(niether is harrison for that matter)

Michael Vick

Rob johnson

Next, I might just have to go with our home boy, Patrick Ramsey....but too early to tell right now.

When healthy, I think Vick is "da man".

Rich Gannon, Kurt Warner, Culpepper can also compete

Vick will be the man, has the most speed by far and has one if not the strongest arm....but he's got to pay some dues and win some big games

i dig vick, but he's gotta learn to beat you with that left cannon. he is electrifying. but as long as he is on the move in this league, he's in DANGER!!!!! he was hurt last year as well. gotta take advantage of that nice comfy pocket more. and when he gets outside that pocket, look for a receiver, can't abandon the pass because he was hurried. what he really needs is a horse in the backfield...stephen davis or ricky williams type. he will also have his work cut out for him when he returns. if atl keeps losing, we'll get to see just how good vick really is. i personally think it'll be the difference between night and day. price will start to look better, so will the rest of the offense upon his return. oh, by the way, remember just 3 short weeks ago, how everyone was sayin how doug johnson could be a starter on most other teams, they kinda sorta aren't talkin that bs anymore. i think even johnson will be glad to see vick assume the starting role.

I am on a big Ramsey for President kick.....gotta do better than "Bush"...at least we know his popularity is higher in the Nation's Capital....He's my pick....and have you seen the price's for his football cards...way up there for most of them compared to other QB's in the league.....

In a year or so - P Ram will be one of the best on a consistent basis.

I would have to say Pennington would get my vote. I know he isn't healthy right now, but neither is Vick. While Mike is awesome - and I got to see him for two years here at Virginia Tech, I think Pennington is the better pure passer.

Mike is likely to keep getting himself hurt, like Cunningham. He can often make poor decisions on the run, throwing to a covered receiver. I think they have worked on that some, but Chad will always be like a sharpshooter, getting better with age. I watched him at Marshall, and the kid was 70%+ for his 4 year career there without a supporting cast for two years after Moss left.

He made Leftwich coming to Marshall seem like a huge letdown.

Unfortunately for Pennington, he was underrated playing in the MAC and for a supposedly weak arm. I don't know about weak, but most QBs can't make the 30 yd out that PRam can anyway, or at least not accurately.

I still say, if Pennington ever gets a WR corps like we have built up around P Ram, watch out. He will light things up.

wow yesterday was big for a couple guys. mcnair finished with more td's than incomplete passes. a 148.2 passer rating. and peyton manning finished with SIX td's, and a perfect passer rating of 158.3.

McNair and Payton did look awesome and deserve some high ranking consideration.

McNair is getting my vote so far. This guy has unseated Favre as the toughest QB in my opinion too.

Manning will return to his 'force it too much' form soon.

Ramsey is the next Favre by the way. Our P-Ram could very well be the best QB in NFC come ProBowl if we can continue.

Brett Farve is the best. He has out lasted all other teams in his ability to stay put.

I think I would take P-Ram over anyone with what he's shown so far, he's my kind of QB... gritty, field general, even at a young age.

... plus, he's the only one I've had my picture taken with.

I was thinking of it in terms of guys I'd like to play against the least. I think my top 5 of that order would be...
Vick
McNabb
McNair
Manning
B.Favre (though his supporting cast is laughable at the moment)

McNair has probably had the most impressive start to this season though.

Can you imagine those 5 with the cast we or say... the Vikings have in the way of WR with a good Oline? Good gosh...

Can you imagine those 5 with the cast we or say... the Vikings have in the way of WR with a good Oline?

Not with a salary cap, I can't

So true ... unfortunately ::grin::

Wow....I forgot about Favre.....ya'll are right....with the right cast....and his fire, look out