Page 1 of 2

Drafting a QB?

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 3:21 pm
by riggofan
I had two questions about drafting a QB that didn't seem to fit in any of the existing draft threads. So, throwing out all of the Mariota stuff, do you think its likely the team will draft a QB this year in one of the mid rounds? Or are we going to ride it out with the current three?

My other question, does anybody have an opinion on Bryce Petty?

I had kind of dismissed him because he's a Baylor QB and well... Reading more on the QBs though he does look like he be the third QB picked from what I can tell. 6'3 230 lbs.

Possesses NFL size. Not a burner, but has enough functional movement outside of the pocket. Scouts label him ultra-competitive, tough and smart. Strong leader. Engineered 21-point fourth-quarter comeback win over TCU in 2014. Played through a back injury for most of his senior season. Doesn't have a cannon, but arm strength is NFL-starter quality. Deep-ball accuracy improved from 2013 to 2014. Understands when to throw the fastball and when to use touch. Gets feet set with good balance on delivery. Keeps ball at proper height on set-up and has quick release. Rarely underthrows deep passes, preferring to give only his wide receiver a chance to catch the ball. Can elude pressure and buy himself time to make a play.


Thoughts?

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 3:51 pm
by SkinsJock
I'd have no problem with them bringing in Petty but I'd find it hard to believe he'll be the BPA or even available - guy's a QB and should go fairly soon

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 5:29 pm
by riggofan
SkinsJock wrote:I'd have no problem with them bringing in Petty but I'd find it hard to believe he'll be the BPA or even available - guy's a QB and should go fairly soon


Yeah I don't really know if he's the BPA or not. That was sort of my question. Just curious if anybody had watched him, had any opinion on him as a player. Like I said, I'm kind of down on QBs from Baylor's system because of the RGIII experience. Maybe that's not entirely fair though.

I still really like the idea of drafting a mid round QB this year if there is one that SM has rated highly. It seems like a pretty weak year for QBs overall though, so maybe we just have to be patient for next year. Supposedly a deeper class in 2016:

http://www.cbssports.com/collegefootbal ... lls-around

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 5:53 pm
by Prowl33
I really like Garrett Grayson and I doubt he drops to round 4 but he is a pretty pro ready qb and I would likevdrafting him around there.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 8:04 pm
by Countertrey
riggofan wrote:
SkinsJock wrote:I'd have no problem with them bringing in Petty but I'd find it hard to believe he'll be the BPA or even available - guy's a QB and should go fairly soon


Yeah I don't really know if he's the BPA or not. That was sort of my question. Just curious if anybody had watched him, had any opinion on him as a player. Like I said, I'm kind of down on QBs from Baylor's system because of the RGIII experience. Maybe that's not entirely fair though.

I still really like the idea of drafting a mid round QB this year if there is one that SM has rated highly. It seems like a pretty weak year for QBs overall though, so maybe we just have to be patient for next year. Supposedly a deeper class in 2016:

http://www.cbssports.com/collegefootbal ... lls-around
I hear you, and have the same thoughts... but, I look at him... and, something in me sees Ben Rothesberger... with nimble feet and a bigger arm. I have a feeling that he could be one of those guys that teams regret not drafting...

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 9:13 pm
by DarthMonk
riggofan wrote:
SkinsJock wrote:I'd have no problem with them bringing in Petty but I'd find it hard to believe he'll be the BPA or even available - guy's a QB and should go fairly soon


Yeah I don't really know if he's the BPA or not. That was sort of my question. Just curious if anybody had watched him, had any opinion on him as a player. Like I said, I'm kind of down on QBs from Baylor's system because of the RGIII experience. Maybe that's not entirely fair though.

I still really like the idea of drafting a mid round QB this year if there is one that SM has rated highly. It seems like a pretty weak year for QBs overall though, so maybe we just have to be patient for next year. Supposedly a deeper class in 2016:

http://www.cbssports.com/collegefootbal ... lls-around


Unless he gets picked "too early" he has to eventually be the BPA - unless he's not in the top 256.

If it's our turn and he's at the top of Scot's board, then by all means pick him.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 8:40 am
by DEHog
Only saw Petty a few times last year and thought he missed a few easy throws. The windows are much tighter in the NFL so I’m not high on him. The Redskins really don’t need to draft a QB, they can sign an arm for camp after the draft. If they move Cousins for a draft pick then I can see them drafting a QB.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 9:28 am
by SkinsJock
DEHog wrote:Only saw Petty a few times last year and thought he missed a few easy throws. The windows are much tighter in the NFL so I’m not high on him. The Redskins really don’t need to draft a QB, they can sign an arm for camp after the draft. If they move Cousins for a draft pick then I can see them drafting a QB.
:shock: This would be an early indicator of the coaches and FO thinking that Griffin is making some progress - if that happens, they definitely are bringing in another QB

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 9:35 am
by riggofan
DEHog wrote:Only saw Petty a few times last year and thought he missed a few easy throws. The windows are much tighter in the NFL so I’m not high on him. The Redskins really don’t need to draft a QB, they can sign an arm for camp after the draft. If they move Cousins for a draft pick then I can see them drafting a QB.


No question that they don't need one this year, and I'm sure they'll bring in a camp arm either way. Let me throw this out to you though. Cousins is likely out of here next year, and you're still not sure whether RGIII can be the guy or can stay healthy. If you can get a capable guy in the 3d or 4th, that guy gets a year as the third string QB and time to learn.

Worst case scenario you have an inexpensive backup again like Cousins has been. Best case, maybe you've given a raw talented guy enough time to consider starting him.

Anyway just curious what people thought of that Petty or any of the other QBs this year. I like the idea above, just not sure the right player will be there.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 9:37 am
by riggofan
Countertrey wrote:I hear you, and have the same thoughts... but, I look at him... and, something in me sees Ben Rothesberger... with nimble feet and a bigger arm. I have a feeling that he could be one of those guys that teams regret not drafting...


I heard the Saints are interested in him. Roethlisberger, eh?

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 9:43 am
by riggofan
SkinsJock wrote:
DEHog wrote:Only saw Petty a few times last year and thought he missed a few easy throws. The windows are much tighter in the NFL so I’m not high on him. The Redskins really don’t need to draft a QB, they can sign an arm for camp after the draft. If they move Cousins for a draft pick then I can see them drafting a QB.
:shock: This would be an early indicator of the coaches and FO thinking that Griffin is making some progress - if that happens, they definitely are bringing in another QB


The draft is tonight. What indication would they have at this point that Griffin is making progress? He hasn't stepped on the field with the team in months.

I don't really think they would draft a QB just because they were able to trade Cousins tonight btw. The right guy still has to be there for them to draft. They have a capable backup in McCoy and there are still jobless QBs out there to sign as a third string.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 9:59 am
by Countertrey
riggofan wrote:
Countertrey wrote:I hear you, and have the same thoughts... but, I look at him... and, something in me sees Ben Rothesberger... with nimble feet and a bigger arm. I have a feeling that he could be one of those guys that teams regret not drafting...


I heard the Saints are interested in him. Roethlisberger, eh?

LOL! Yup. Book mark it. This guy will be sliding around, making passes with guys hanging on him, buying time in the pocket... :wink:

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 10:06 am
by SkinsJock
I'm not at all suggesting that they might draft a QB this year

if they decide to get a pick for Cousins which I think is fine - they need to bring in another QB is all

why would they be OK with moving Cousins - he seems like a decent back up and Griffin still has a lot to prove - maybe because they know more about how Griffin is responding to all the criticism about his future than we all do

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 10:18 am
by OldSchool
I can see Griffin getting cut and Cousins bailing in 2016 for a team that will at least tell him they are going let him compete for a starting job. One of the me is gone for sure in and maybe both so if they find a guy with pocket passing skills in a late rounds pick him up. But only use a late round IMHO because they need to use the top rounds develop a better supporting cast.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 10:42 am
by DarthMonk
NFL exec: Garrett Grayson could be top QB of 2015 draft class

By Chase Goodbread
College Football 24/7 writer
Published: April 27, 2015 at 12:48 p.m

Jameis Winston and Marcus Mariota are expected to be the only quarterbacks selected Thursday in the first round of the NFL draft, despite questions -- albeit very different ones -- about their ability to succeed as the offensive cornerstone of an NFL franchise.

However, for one NFL executive, the correct draft lever to pull at the quarterback position might not have either of their names on it.

"I wouldn't be surprised if (Colorado State's Garrett) Grayson was better than all of them," the executive told USA Today Sports. "I just think he's got the intangibles. He's got a good presence about himself in the pocket. He's got the physical traits. His arm's strong enough, and I think he's got the right temperament."

Citing Grayson's poise and ability to read the field, NFL Media analyst Daniel Jeremiah rated Grayson as the third-best quarterback prospect in the draft more than two months ago, prior to the NFL Scouting Combine. But Grayson might not be picked in Round 2, or even on Day 2 (Rounds 2-3). Representatives from three NFC clubs told The Coloradoan that they have mid- to late-round grades on Grayson, and the one who believes he could be the best of the draft class actually has him rated as the No. 4 QB available. Baylor's Bryce Petty and UCLA's Brett Hundley are also contenders to be the third quarterback selected.

It all makes for a muddy picture at the position after the Winston and Mariota drama passes with their selections.

The primary concern NFL scouts have about Winston is his maturity. For Mariota, it's his adaptability to a pro-style offense. For Grayson, neither appears to be an issue.

"I met with the Rams last week and got up on the board drawing some of their offensive plays. Some of their plays were literally the exact same plays, same verbiage (as CSU)," Grayson told The Coloradoan. "Things like that have definitely helped me up through this process."

The New Orleans Saints will put Grayson through his fifth private workout Monday, and the St. Louis Rams, Miami Dolphins, San Diego Chargers and Dallas Cowboys are the other teams that have worked him out, according to the report.


Link with conversation and video: http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap300000 ... raft-class

If we are on the clock on day 2 and this guy is definitively at the top of Scot's board then, we will pick him in a heartbeat.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 10:52 am
by SkinsJock
the closer it gets the more weird the information being 'released' by the franchises - everyone has an agenda today

misleading information and outright lying is standard fare

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 10:59 am
by riggofan
SkinsJock wrote:why would they be OK with moving Cousins - he seems like a decent back up and Griffin still has a lot to prove - maybe because they know more about how Griffin is responding to all the criticism about his future than we all do


Maybe I guess. The guy was our third string QB last year though and we have McCoy. Maybe they think they've hit Cousins' ceiling already? Maybe they know he's gone in 2016, so if somebody offered a draft pick for him it would be better than getting nothing for him later?

Just speculation. I still find the whole Cousins thing last year pretty bizarre.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 11:01 am
by riggofan
SkinsJock wrote:the closer it gets the more weird the information being 'released' by the franchises - everyone has an agenda today

misleading information and outright lying is standard fare


I know it man. I always wonder (and worry) if some of these last minute negative stories about some of these picks is coming from teams trying to get them to drop.

I was reading today about Randy Gregory that "some teams question if he is too skinny to be effective in the NFL". Huh? #-o That guy was being touted as a top 5 pick just three weeks ago!!!

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 11:34 am
by Deadskins
If we draft a QB, then one of the three under contract has to go. No way are we carrying four into the season. My guess would be Cousins, because I don't think RGIII is going anywhere, and teams already could have gotten McCoy when he was a FA, if they wanted him. Now, this doesn't necessarily mean that the trade has to happen before, or during the draft (though that is most likely), but if we draft a QB, you can pretty much guarantee Kirk has played his last game for the burgundy and gold.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 12:28 pm
by riggofan
Deadskins wrote:If we draft a QB, then one of the three under contract has to go. No way are we carrying four into the season.


Of course. Personally I wish we were in position where we only had to carry two QBs on the roster.

Deadskins wrote:My guess would be Cousins, because I don't think RGIII is going anywhere, and teams already could have gotten McCoy when he was a FA, if they wanted him. Now, this doesn't necessarily mean that the trade has to happen before, or during the draft (though that is most likely), but if we draft a QB, you can pretty much guarantee Kirk has played his last game for the burgundy and gold.


I would guess Cousins too. Mostly because they were so weird about him last year.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 1:36 pm
by DarthMonk
Deadskins wrote:If we draft a QB, then one of the three under contract has to go. No way are we carrying four into the season. My guess would be Cousins, because I don't think RGIII is going anywhere, and teams already could have gotten McCoy when he was a FA, if they wanted him. Now, this doesn't necessarily mean that the trade has to happen before, or during the draft (though that is most likely), but if we draft a QB, you can pretty much guarantee Kirk has played his last game for the burgundy and gold.


How much money would we have spent on Colt this year and what would the cap hit be if we cut him in mid-August?

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 1:39 pm
by OldSchool
I think you are right. Cousins wants a chance to compete for a starting job so he's going to leave in 2016 for any team that gives him a chance to compete. The Skins would be smart to trade him for a late round and draft a rookie to take his place. After exercising the 16M option the Skins are totally committed again to Griffin as their starter and cutting Griffin for another franchise QB pick for 2016 if Griffin doesn't step it up. McCoy is content to be a long term backup but until he fails again Cousins won't be so you might as well get some value in a draft pick for him and take another young development project in a late round.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 2:20 pm
by riggofan
DarthMonk wrote:
Deadskins wrote:If we draft a QB, then one of the three under contract has to go. No way are we carrying four into the season. My guess would be Cousins, because I don't think RGIII is going anywhere, and teams already could have gotten McCoy when he was a FA, if they wanted him. Now, this doesn't necessarily mean that the trade has to happen before, or during the draft (though that is most likely), but if we draft a QB, you can pretty much guarantee Kirk has played his last game for the burgundy and gold.


How much money would we have spent on Colt this year and what would the cap hit be if we cut him in mid-August?


Its a $1.5m contract for the year with only the $150K signing bonus guaranteed. He has a roster bonus of $156K that he'll hit before August I think. That $300K is the dead cap space for the year if he gets cut in August. I'm not sure when his base salary starts getting prorated and added to that number. Either way its not a killer.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 3:26 pm
by DarthMonk
riggofan wrote:
DarthMonk wrote:
Deadskins wrote:If we draft a QB, then one of the three under contract has to go. No way are we carrying four into the season. My guess would be Cousins, because I don't think RGIII is going anywhere, and teams already could have gotten McCoy when he was a FA, if they wanted him. Now, this doesn't necessarily mean that the trade has to happen before, or during the draft (though that is most likely), but if we draft a QB, you can pretty much guarantee Kirk has played his last game for the burgundy and gold.


How much money would we have spent on Colt this year and what would the cap hit be if we cut him in mid-August?


Its a $1.5m contract for the year with only the $150K signing bonus guaranteed. He has a roster bonus of $156K that he'll hit before August I think. That $300K is the dead cap space for the year if he gets cut in August. I'm not sure when his base salary starts getting prorated and added to that number. Either way its not a killer.


So it seems we could easily ...

Draft a QB,

Keep him,

Release Colt,

Watch Griff succeed or not, and

React appropriately.

Re: Drafting a QB?

Posted: Thu Apr 30, 2015 3:48 pm
by SkinsJock
the offense is going to be a work in progress - the most important position is certainly a huge question mark and the line obviously will need some time - after 4 seasons, Dallas finally got a decent O line after using 1st round picks on O line for 3 drafts

I doubt we're that far away but it certainly gives us a couple of drafts to figure out where we are at QB

hopefully Griffin becomes a good NFL QB - I doubt that BPA is a QB - there's just not that many ... but then again, you never know for sure