Page 1 of 1
Redskin All-Time Team Nominations - Left Guard
Posted: Mon Feb 18, 2013 9:15 pm
by DarthMonk
Taking nominations for left guard. I'll try to come to a consensus for the top 3 and then use the run-off method in a poll.
Historians please help sort these names in terms of left or right guard. If you know a guy played predominantly on the right side, please flag him. Remember, we need a starter and a back-up at every position.
If I missed someone important, please nominate.
Ray Schoenke
Paul Laaveg
Terry Hermeling
Ron Saul
Fred Dean
Russ Grimm
Ray Brown
Raleigh McKenzie
Tre Johnson
Derrick Dockery
Randy Thomas
Kory Lichtensteiger
Posted: Tue Feb 19, 2013 1:15 am
by The Hogster
Save yourself the time, and just give it to Russ Grimm now. Move on to a position that is actually debatable.
Posted: Tue Feb 19, 2013 7:46 am
by Countertrey
^
Posted: Tue Feb 19, 2013 10:09 am
by GFlanagan3
ummm yep..Grimm..no contest..next?
Re: Redskin All-Time Team Nominations - Left Guard
Posted: Tue Feb 19, 2013 2:51 pm
by DarthMonk
The Hogster wrote:Save yourself the time, and just give it to Russ Grimm now. Move on to a position that is actually debatable.
The Hogster wrote:Read slower - snip -
DarthMonk wrote: Remember, we need a starter and a back-up at every position.
Also, I need help sorting out the
RIGHT guards from the left.
Thanks.
Re: Redskin All-Time Team Nominations - Left Guard
Posted: Tue Feb 19, 2013 9:00 pm
by Deadskins
DarthMonk wrote:Also, I need help sorting out the RIGHT guards
Stick
Aerosol
Roll-on
Posted: Tue Feb 19, 2013 9:48 pm
by The Hogster
RG = Mark May
Posted: Wed Feb 20, 2013 9:39 am
by PulpExposure
The Hogster wrote:Save yourself the time, and just give it to Russ Grimm now. Move on to a position that is actually debatable.
<----Agreed.
Posted: Wed Feb 20, 2013 2:39 pm
by DarthMonk
The Hogster wrote:RG = Mark May
At least that was helpful.
I still need to know which of the guys on my list are right guards and not left. For some reason I thought May was predominantly a RT but whateva. I'll check that one.
Can some "old-timers" please help. I get the hole Grimm thing (duh) but we still need a back-up at LG and I need to know who belongs on the ballot.
Thanks.
Here's the list of guards, left and right and perhaps Mark May depending what I find concerning where he played most.
DarthMonk wrote:Taking nominations for left guard. I'll try to come to a consensus for the top 3 and then use the run-off method in a poll.
Historians please help sort these names in terms of left or right guard. If you know a guy played predominantly on the right side, please flag him. Remember, we need a starter and a back-up at every position.
If I missed someone important, please nominate.
Ray Schoenke
Paul Laaveg
Terry Hermeling
Ron Saul
Fred Dean
Russ Grimm
Ray Brown
Raleigh McKenzie
Tre Johnson
Derrick Dockery
Randy Thomas
Kory Lichtensteiger
Posted: Wed Feb 20, 2013 7:10 pm
by DarthMonk
I got the original list off a site I found for Redskin rosters by year. I then cross checked against pro-footballreference.com and got this:
LGs:
Ray Schoenke
Paul Laaveg
Ron Saul
Russ Grimm
Ray Brown
Derrick Dockery
Kory Lichtensteiger
RGs:
Randy Thomas
*Raleigh McKenzie - spent 5 seasons each at LG, C, and RG !!!
*Tre Johnson - spent equal time at LG and RG
xTerry Hermeling - mostly a LT, only 2 years at RG
xFred Dean - gone
Mark May was predominantly a RT.
I need a consensus on the top 3 LGs so I can run a poll run-off style to establish the top 2 LGs (a starter and a back-up) in Redskin history. I lean (chronologically) toward ...
Ray Schoenke,
Russ Grimm, and
Ray Brown.
Unless I hear some strong arguments I'm gonna start the LG poll in a few days with these 3.
Posted: Thu Feb 21, 2013 3:49 pm
by crazyhorse1
DarthMonk wrote:I got the original list off a site I found for Redskin rosters by year. I then cross checked against pro-footballreference.com and got this:
LGs:
Ray Schoenke
Paul Laaveg
Ron Saul
Russ Grimm
Ray Brown
Derrick Dockery
Kory Lichtensteiger
RGs:
Randy Thomas
*Raleigh McKenzie - spent 5 seasons each at LG, C, and RG !!!
Grimm by a mile, Thomas next. What is Dockery doing up there? Lichtensteiger?
*Tre Johnson - spent equal time at LG and RG
xTerry Hermeling - mostly a LT, only 2 years at RG
xFred Dean - gone
Mark May was predominantly a RT.
I need a consensus on the top 3 LGs so I can run a poll run-off style to establish the top 2 LGs (a starter and a back-up) in Redskin history. I lean (chronologically) toward ...
Ray Schoenke,
Russ Grimm, and
Ray Brown.
Unless I hear some strong arguments I'm gonna start the LG poll in a few days with these 3.