Posted: Thu Aug 27, 2009 6:55 pm
KazooSkinsFan wrote:SnyderSucks wrote:No, that's been the argument all along
The discussion I was in with you was you just generally said Snyder had trouble re-signing players. An assertion you haven't backed up with much by way of example.
So if now we're arguing he should sign specifically before contracts are up, I gave you a pretty good description of why that's difficult. Most players in their rookie contract won't do that unless you sign them to a contract which assumes they will walk on water, otherwise they'd rather try to walk on water. You also lose the rookie pay years, you're paying them more sooner. I'm having a really hard time seeing this big cap savings you're claiming.
But you like to throw out these general statements, so let's go back to my question on examples. You say you can sign players before their contract is up as a policy, I said why you can't. Easy way to resolve it. So, which teams are doing it successfully? Who are you looking to us to emulate and who have they done this with?
I already said that Philadelphia does it the best. Pittsburgh also does. New York just did it with their QB, as did San Diego. You don't think they have trouble resigning players? Who have they resigned that made it to free agency? Betts. Other than that, no one.

The Eagles gave Westbrook an extension last season. The gave McNabb a raise for this year and next despite no contractual requirement to do so. Sheldon Brown was given an extension in 2004, two years into his rookie deal. It's their policy to do extensions a couple of years into the rookie contract. The re-signed Joselio Hanson to a deal prior to him reaching free agency this spring. I'm not an eagles fan, so I don't have a complete list for you.