^
You have to wonder if Banks’ best shot at making a case for himself already has come and gone. With all the other players the coaches have to look at, all the other things the offense has to work on, it’s hard to imagine the quarterbacks targeting him nine times (or anything close) in any of the remaining preseason games. Indeed, the only way for him to carve a roster spot for himself might be to do something spectacular in the return game, something that causes Shanahan to rethink his planning and say to himself, “I can’t cut this kid. He’s too much of a playmaker.”
I think right here, this guy's argument is spot on.
1. His test as a receiver in preseason games, may have come and gone. Although one report, says the that scheme the defense is running dictates who gets the passes, so Brandon may get a pass or two on Saturday.
2. He only makes the team as a playmaker. I agree, but I don't beileve that that is limited to kick returns - Banks has been a playmaker from scrimmage - reverses and the pass.
Shanny has tried the wildcat and also keeps trying the bubble screens. This is Banks first year to be 100% (he has
never missed a game despite having knee surgery during the season. ). I think that Shanny is excited about that. It is clear that Shanny likes the explosiveness that Banks' possesses. He has even said so.
About the KO average drop - the writer points out that Banks dropped outside the top 20 in KO returns, but in comparison, Banks topped still topped Devin Hestor on KORs. This is not to say he is better than Hestor, I am saying that for coaches, there are more variables to consider when evaluating the effectiveness of a returner. Concerning punts, Banks' average dropped, but he was 3rd in the NFL (Hestor was #1) on returns over 20 yards. This is the chunk yardage that Danny Smith spoke about.
Yes, some of the passes were off target, but there also were times when Banks didn’t create enough space for himself to make the grab. Clearly, his size (5-foot-7, 150 pounds), which can be an asset in the return game by rendering him almost invisible, works against him as a wideout because he’s invariably battling bigger defenders, guys with more reach.
The writer correctly defines a big problem for Banks on some plays - separation, but he fails to mention that Banks got open on both deep balls (after rewatching the first deep ball, Banks appeared to be going by the defender - the tell tale sign is the defender tried to arm bar him, but then Banks had to come back for the ball). The writer also doesn't discuss the slipping which is a common problem for poor route runners (I believe that Banks was a victim of his nerves - I defer to practice reports).
The part about his
size working against his as a wideout - that is true of any small wideout. To some fans and some media, it might be a revelation - wow, the little guy is being out jumped or can't shield the bigger defenders. I am saying that this is
not an issue [color=yellow]concerning his evaluation as a wideout,[/color] because Shanny and other coaches, some fans, some media,
know that small wideouts have limitations (some folks flat out
don't like their receivers small. Nothing wrong with that; however,
Shanny clearly feels that Banks, with his size and a little dedication to the game, can compete for a wideout job. Shanahan who has seen Banks in practice is not going to be expecting
"Air Jordan Banks" in the games. Uh Brandon, you need to work on your routes and can you grow a little bit before Saturday? or how about this one, Brandon, you size is working against you out there, I don't know what I was thinking putting you out there. I know the media has to generate readers and outside of RGIII, Banks was maybe the next biggest topic.
It was reasonable to expect Banks, who had all offseason to perfect his route running, to come out humming. He did it in the 11 on 11 practice
where his size didn't matter. (somehow to some of the same media, writers were it mattered in the game). Brandon's poor showing was do to poor receiver mechanics and nothing else, but I guarantee you that Shannahan saw some positives. Mechanics can be fixed, but as the writer asks,
is it too late?. As Banks, said, he knows he had his chance. He knows that he needs to do better.