SkinsFreak wrote:CanesSkins26 wrote:Campbell may develop into a very good QB but that is certainly not a given and look at how long he's been here and we are still not sure that he's a top 10 QB in the NFL - no wonder we are not one of the teams that people consider a certainty for the playoffs Twisted Evil
Campbell isn't anywhere close to being one of the top 10 best qbs in the NFL. It really is quite sad how poor our qb situation has been over the last ten years or so. Since 1999 all of following players have started at least one game for us:
Brad Johnson
Tony Banks
Jeff George
Shane Matthews
Patrick Ramsey
Danny Wuerffel
Tim Hasselbeck
Mark Brunell
Jason Campbell
Todd Collins
9 seasons and 10 different qbs that have started games for us.
I agree that's a less than impressive list
In that case I think you are both wrong.

It is perhaps on the 'heavier' side but really not uncommon at all.
What is a list that goes back 10 years supposed to tell us? Are we supposed to make inferences about QB rotation and succes?
Personally, I think that list is somewhat pointless (perhaps disingenuous — not that CanesSkins is, but that the list comes across as "worse" than it really is)
Here are five other teams that have similar QB profiles and have had varying degrees of success over the last ten years. (Together with the Skins, that's 20% of the league, btw.) One team (Arizona) is a recent success, although they've been solidly building in the last few years, culminating in the Super Bowl. Some teams have been successful throughout the 10 years. Some have been teams people cite for solid QB play. Others have had Super Bowl victories and/or appearances in the last 10 years. At any rate, all of the quarterbacks on this list meet CanesSkins criteria:
Cardinals (8 QBs in 10 years; Super Bowl appearance; known for good QB play [Warner, Plummer]):
Kurt Warner
Matt Leinhart
Josh McCown
Shaun King
John Navarre
Jeff Blake
Jake Plummer
Dave Brown
Carolina Panthers (9 QBs in 10 years; Super Bowl appearance; multiple playoff appearances; known for good QB play):
Jake Delhomme
Vinny Testaverde
David Carr
Matt Moore
Chris Weinke
Rodney Peete
Randy Fasani
Matt Lyttle
Steve Beuerlein
Baltimore Ravens (12 QBs in 10 years; Super Bowl appearance; multiple playoff appearances):
Joe Flacco
Kyle Boller
Steve McNair
Troy Smith
Anthony Wright
Chris Redman
Jeff Blake
Elvis Grbac
Randall Cunningham
Tony Banks
Trent Dilfer
Stoney Case
Tampa Bay (11 QBs in 10 years; Super Bowl victory; multiple playoff appearances; only 3 losing seasons)
Jeff Garcia
Brian Griese
Luke McCown
Bruce Gradkowski
Chris Simms
Tim Rattay
Brian Griese
Brad Johnson
Rob Johnson
Shaun King
Eric Zeier
St. Louis (10 QBs in 10 years; Super Bowl victory; multiple Super Bowl appearances; multiple playoff appearances; known for good QB play [Warner, Bulger]):
Marc Bulger
Trent Green
Gus Frerotte
Brock Berlin
Jamie Martin
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Chris Chander
Kurt Warner
Scott Covington
Trent Green
There's SOME merit to the study. New England and Indianapolis come to mind as teams with a lot of stability at QB—basically one guy for the last ten years. New York, Philly, Green Bay are some others who have been successful and have had stability.
But most teams that are successful (i.e., make the playoffs) often don't have QB stability,
especially stability going back 10 years. That's such a random stat to pull out of the hat.
. . .And, there are other teams with the stability CanesSkins is looking for but who haven't been impressive: the Texans, Minnesota Vikings, and the Buffalo Bills. So there really isn't too much correlation one way or the other. Instead of talking about "quarterback stability" in the abstract, it's better to identify who the superstars are (Brady, Manning, etc.) and work from there.
But then, that wouldn't put the Skins in the worst possible light.
