chaddukes wrote:I agree that he needs to start now. We have to see what he has. But there is a difference between Romo and Campbell. Romo has been in the same offense for a couple of years, and he did enough in proactice to give Parcells confidence in him. Campbell apparently hasn't impressed many people at Redskins Park. We don't see anything of Campbell, but the coaching staff does. They don't seem to think that he is ready.....which is why Collins is the backup!
It's more than that. If Parcells thought so much of Romo, why wasn't he a starter from Opening Day? Parcells, like Gibbs, initially wanted to play it safe and go with the vet. However, he saw it wasn't working out (like here), and before the season was completely done (unlike here), he decided to make the switch. Going with the young guy is a gamble, no doubt, but sometimes you've got to take a big risk to gain a big reward. So far, it looks like Parcell's gamble has paid off. Here, we've got coaches determined to play it safe, even if that means becoming predictable, which gets you killed in this league. They're not willing to risk anything to win, out of fear of losing, but we're losing nonetheless. It may be that Campbell just isn't that good and we wasted three picks on him, but I've never believed he's been given a fair shot. Gibbs has always believed vets are automatically better, and Campbell would have to be amazing to even have Gibbs consider playing him ahead of Brunell. It's hard to know what the truth is until Campbell has at least a season under his belt, but having watched the Brunell/Ramsey soap opera in '04, I don't believe Brunell is simply better as he's playing right now.