The Hogster wrote:chiefhog44 wrote:The Hogster wrote:chiefhog44 wrote:The Hogster wrote:None of you guys know what Manning will want to do. But, taking an educated guess given what we know, I highly doubt he'd want to be here.
First, business wise it makes no sense. The Manning Family is a brand. If Peyton is here, only one of the Mannings would be able to win a division title each year which significantly reduces the likelihood that they (i) will both have a chance to make the playoffs yearly, and (ii) eliminates the chance of both making the Superbowl. Putting them in the same division will hamper the overall success of the Manning brand.
Secondly, Manning has been in the same offense his entire career. (i) One of the architects of that offense happens to be with the New York Jets. (ii) The Jets happen to have a QB under scrutiny. (iii) The Jets happen to be in the AFC, thus allowing both Manning brothers the chance to consistently make the playoffs, Superbowls & have success. (iv) And, NY happens to be the biggest market in the league.
For those reasons I believe that the NYJ would have the edge not only for football reasons, but for business reasons.
So let me get this straight. The division is too small for the both of them but the city of New York isn't? Does anybody else smell the odor coming from this? Peeeeeeyou
Um, yes. Duh. There are two successful franchises in NY that are in different CONFERENCES. Meaning, both Mannings have a shot to succeed consistently while both being in NYC. They don't have the same opportunity for consistent success when they are both within the same DIVISION. Maybe you don't understand that, but if you have any business and/or football sense you do.
First off, I'm laughing AT your statements, not debating them, but for laughs, the thought that the two of them can't be in the same division because of some "Manning family brand" is silly. Like the two have to be in different conferences for there to be any success. I actually think just the opposite. It would give the league a huge promotion TWICE a year. Hell, how bout a matchup in the playoffs. The likelihood that they'll be in the Super Bowl at the same time is extremely low in the amount of years he's got left.
Secondly, you speak about the Colts architect in NY? Who might that be? If you're thinking Tom Moore, the guy isn't even working there anymore. Maybe I'm missing someone, so I'll let you explain.
Wow. This is remedial. If you don't understand why Peyton Manning might rather not compete with his brother in-division, then you're just...helpless. Additionally, if you don't think the Manning's are a brand, you're not paying attention. Finally, if you think Tom Moore would not serve as an offensive consultant to the Jets next season (as he did this season) if Peyton went there, well then....no help for you there.
Either way, you're misinformed and I don't have to walk you through these concepts.
I could ask you to explain why the aforementioned football and business reasons don't support my preposition, but that would require you to think. But just for giggles, why on earth would Peyton want to come to D.C. sense such a logical argument could be made.
Kyle is younger than him. Totally new offense. Skins have one half the games the Jets have in the last 2 years. Oh, and he'd have to beat his younger brother to get to the Superbowl. Brilliant.
Guess I'm helpless, and not paying attention, but for once, how about considering a different view than your own for more than a nanosecond before you shred someone's business or football knowledge because it differs with your own. It's getting old sitting here listening to your righteous tone with everyone.
What is a Manning family brand? As if Archie is sitting back collecting all the revenues of these two. Do you not think these two players are individuals, making decisions based on their own individual brand names? I have no idea what you are even talking about so you're gonna HAVE to explain it.
Even if you meant individual brand names, maybe you get by with saying that they are concerned about their individual brand when they're rookies or even second or third year starters, but these guys have both won Super Bowls, been to countless playoffs etc. Hell Peyton just made 25+million last year for not even playing. The brand is built, and for Peyton, almost done. Further, they've played in different conferences forever while growing their individual brand names... I dont think it's so far fecthed as you to think they would be opposed to playing against each other in a VERY rich division. I think financially, the league would absolutely LOVE the idea of these guys playing against each other twice a year, and I think they obviously would individually profit as well. Hmm, let's put this together, like a businessman...top five revenue team in the league without an allstar on the roster. Peyton goes to the team and guess what happens? I'll let you draw the conclusion since, well, you know it all.
Secondly, sorry, you made the comment of Tom Moore being on the Jets...which he is not. But yet, STILL, you can't even admit when you are actually wrong. Do those that you know personally get as frustrated as we all do listening to this hardheadedness?
Thirdly, I NEVER said that he would WANT to come here. I have no idea what he would want. I'm simply laughing at the Manning Family brand comment, and correcting you on the Tom Moore statement.