Page 5 of 8
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 2:55 pm
by Redskin in Canada
riggofan wrote:Yeah you're 100% correct - that's why I'm concerned about the fans and the media. It often seems to me when Snyder makes these moves like he is reacting to the fans' negativity or reacting to what is out there in the media rather than doing what is best for the team.
No. You should be less concerned about media and fans, and far more concerned about the "Schottenheimer Syndrome" which is ...
Good or bad season, progress or not, the owner decides that it is just not as much "fun" to become a respectful owner but wishes to come back and play as President/GM after a single season regardless of the progress achieved by those previously in charge.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 3:22 pm
by riggofan
Redskin in Canada wrote:riggofan wrote:Yeah you're 100% correct - that's why I'm concerned about the fans and the media. It often seems to me when Snyder makes these moves like he is reacting to the fans' negativity or reacting to what is out there in the media rather than doing what is best for the team.
No. You should be less concerned about media and fans, and far more concerned about the "Schottenheimer Syndrome" which is ...
Good or bad season, progress or not, the owner decides that it is just not as much "fun" to become a respectful owner but wishes to come back and play as President/GM after a single season regardless of the progress achieved by those previously in charge.
hah - I'm worried about that too! Did you see Vinny's anecdotes about Snyder/Schottenheimer this week?
On the Schottenheimer-Snyder friction
“What it was, was Dan did not enjoy owning the football team,” Cerrato said. “Marty acted like HE owned the team. And what happened was was he got into it with Dan’s partner during training camp, telling him what to do and what he could do and what he couldn’t do, and then his partner kind of set Marty straight, said listen, we sign your paycheck….Dan called me to come back right the day the season ended. He called me and I said I’m not coming back if Marty’s there. He said don’t worry about that, he’s gone.”
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/dc- ... s-stories/I still think Snyder gets affected by the noise in the media though. I see you're in Canada, so not sure if you're aware how insane and ugly it gets here with people just KILLING the team 24/7 on the radio. We can be in the middle of March Madness, and they'll still be beating up the Redskins in the local media.
I honestly believe Bruce Allen's horrible press conference and the howling media reaction to it played a big part in this new GM hire. You notice when Allen held that press conference there wasn't anything said at all about possibly looking to hire a GM. It was pretty much completely the opposite, business as usual. We should be thanking Allen for being so smug, smarmy and unprepared for that press conference.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 3:29 pm
by Deadskins
riggofan wrote:Redskin in Canada wrote:riggofan wrote:Yeah you're 100% correct - that's why I'm concerned about the fans and the media. It often seems to me when Snyder makes these moves like he is reacting to the fans' negativity or reacting to what is out there in the media rather than doing what is best for the team.
No. You should be less concerned about media and fans, and far more concerned about the "Schottenheimer Syndrome" which is ...
Good or bad season, progress or not, the owner decides that it is just not as much "fun" to become a respectful owner but wishes to come back and play as President/GM after a single season regardless of the progress achieved by those previously in charge.
hah - I'm worried about that too! Did you see Vinny's anecdotes about Snyder/Schottenheimer this week?
On the Schottenheimer-Snyder friction
“What it was, was Dan did not enjoy owning the football team,” Cerrato said. “Marty acted like HE owned the team. And what happened was was he got into it with Dan’s partner during training camp, telling him what to do and what he could do and what he couldn’t do, and then his partner kind of set Marty straight, said listen, we sign your paycheck….Dan called me to come back right the day the season ended. He called me and I said I’m not coming back if Marty’s there. He said don’t worry about that, he’s gone.”
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/dc- ... s-stories/
You should take anything VC says about Schotty with a grain of salt. The first thing Marty did when he came to DC was fire Vinny. The first thing Danny did after firing Marty was bring back Vinny. Maybe Vinny was the "partner" in that anecdote.

Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 4:51 pm
by Redskin in Canada
riggofan wrote:Redskin in Canada wrote:I honestly believe Bruce Allen's horrible press conference and the howling media reaction to it played a big part in this new GM hire. You notice when Allen held that press conference there wasn't anything said at all about possibly looking to hire a GM. It was pretty much completely the opposite, business as usual. We should be thanking Allen for being so smug, smarmy and unprepared for that press conference.
Wrong. The decision to bring a new GM had been made before that terrible press conference.
Nothing in the two posts above dispels or alleviates the fear that the owner may fall to the "Schottenheimer Syndrome" again. My fear is his sick and obsessive search for vindication. A search that not only involves winning but also being directly involved in it. A psychotherapists case, I know. But for that reason, we all are cautiously interested but there is a looooong way to go, beyond a single season, to determine if a substantial change has occurred.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 4:54 pm
by emoses14
Even now, every time I hear vinny cerrato say anything or read a quote from him, my first reaction is to laugh. I'm sure he's a highly functional human being, but I just can't get this picture out of my mind:

Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 5:22 pm
by riggofan
Redskin in Canada wrote:riggofan wrote:Redskin in Canada wrote:I honestly believe Bruce Allen's horrible press conference and the howling media reaction to it played a big part in this new GM hire. You notice when Allen held that press conference there wasn't anything said at all about possibly looking to hire a GM. It was pretty much completely the opposite, business as usual. We should be thanking Allen for being so smug, smarmy and unprepared for that press conference.
Wrong. The decision to bring a new GM had been made before that terrible press conference.
What do you mean "wrong"? What evidence do you have of when the decision to hire a GM was made? Please share.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 5:39 pm
by SkinsJock
Part way through last season, when I found out that RG3 was basically brought here by Snyder and Allen, I started to think that a lot of the information we were given about this athlete might have been put together by 'marketing' people ... and then I looked at the offense that we were using in 2012 and thought, maybe ... and finally, when you realize that a decent young offensive minded HC like Jay Gruden, who was primarily brought here by dumb and dumber II, to 'help' RG3, quickly realized that RG3 did not have the basic mechanics needed to be able to run the offense ... then I started to look at the whole picture and realized these 2 bozos were still involved with meddling with this franchise
I'm very disappointed but I now understand that Dan Snyder is the root cause of the issues this franchise is facing - all of them
If Snyder gives this new GM the opportunity to fix this mess, we have a chance ..
the only question is, how long will he be able to keep his grimy little fingers out of the operations side of this franchise
many of us really know that Dan Snyder cannot be trusted
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 8:07 pm
by Prowl33
Skins have now official announced it. Press conference tomorrow.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 10:48 pm
by tribeofjudah
Beathard LIKE the hiring of Scot...
Former Redskins general manager Bobby Beathard is a “real fan” of the next Redskins general manager, Scot McCloughan.
“I think he’ll do a great job for the Redskins,” Beathard said Thursday on ESPN980, noting that he knows McCloughan and his father, Kent, who was a long time scout for Oakland. “I don’t have any doubts about it.”
“I think [team president] Bruce [Allen] will be hands off, let him run this thing,” Beathard continued. “[Allen] recognizes the talent this guy has. Bruce knows him. I think it’s the perfect hire. Every aspect of it, from his ability as a talent scout to his getting along with people. He knew coming in what it would be like working with Bruce, and he figured it would be a great situation. I don’t think he’d have taken the job if he hadn’t felt that way.”
http://www.csnwashington.com/redskinsbl ... mccloughan
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 11:20 pm
by OldSchool
i'm an alcoholic also, had my last drink in July of 1981. I have never heard of a drinker who abused as bad as he described who successfully dialed down to "1 beer." Once a cucumber becomes a pickle you can't reverse the process. I have heard of lots of guys who dryed up totally for a few months and were able to limit their drinking for a short period of time but inevitably things fall apart and they are back in the same mess as before, I did this a couple of times myself before finally throwing in the towel and fully accepting my alcoholism and stopping totally. Alcoholics will rationalize and come up with all sorts of stories and theories to explain doing what they know they shouldn't do I wish this man the best, forget about the Skins, I just hope this man gets well.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2015 11:39 pm
by tribeofjudah
He needs AA and a sponsor and support. He needs Near Beer or Odouls?
NO.......he just needs to have a CLEAR mind and get us studs in the draft and free agency.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 12:45 am
by Prowl33
Wondering if McCloughan will get rid of RG3. From what I see the guy likes to build a good locker room atmosphere of players... and RG3 to me is the opposite of that. If we are gonna have a locker room full of team players, and not in it for themselves diva's, I dont see how RG3 stays.
Plus ive read a couple places he was high on Cousins in tge draft but had Wilson scored slightly higher... could be a sign we see cousins start next year as a temporary solution unless he can prove otherwise.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 9:35 am
by DarthMonk
Prowl33 wrote:Wondering if McCloughan will get rid of RG3. From what I see the guy likes to build a good locker room atmosphere of players... and RG3 to me is the opposite of that. If we are gonna have a locker room full of team players, and not in it for themselves diva's, I dont see how RG3 stays.
Plus ive read a couple places he was high on Cousins in tge draft but had Wilson scored slightly higher... could be a sign we see cousins start next year as a temporary solution unless he can prove otherwise.
I think I read that if Wilson had been gone when they picked in the 3rd round they were gonna use that pick on Captain Kirk.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 9:57 am
by Chris Luva Luva
Prowl33 wrote:From what I see the guy likes to build a good locker room atmosphere of players... and RG3 to me is the opposite of that. If we are gonna have a locker room full of team players, and not in it for themselves diva's, I dont see how RG3 stays.
You've been in the locker room? Because all reports seem to indicate the opposite of what you're saying, as far as his locker room presence is concerned.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 10:30 am
by Prowl33
Chris Luva Luva wrote:Prowl33 wrote:From what I see the guy likes to build a good locker room atmosphere of players... and RG3 to me is the opposite of that. If we are gonna have a locker room full of team players, and not in it for themselves diva's, I dont see how RG3 stays.
You've been in the locker room? Because all reports seem to indicate the opposite of what you're saying, as far as his locker room presence is concerned.
Ive seen reports saying he isolates himself and that team mates are tired of the attention he seeks in social media and how he comes across in his press conferences.
Listen to his press conferences before and after the Gruden conference where he got ripped. Before he always sounds like the good is him and defers taking direct accountability for the bad. After he sounds forced and fake when he gives his team mates credit, and when asked about his bad play specifically instead of manning up and taking responsibility, he just uses the "we" statements and never any "me" or "I"
If you are good at reading people, you will easily see hevreally thinks he has no faults, he thinks everything that goes wrong is everyone elses fault, and takes no direct responsibility for anything.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 10:48 am
by gibbsfan
tribeofjudah wrote:He needs AA and a sponsor and support. He needs Near Beer or Odouls?
NO.......he just needs to have a CLEAR mind and get us studs in the draft and free agency.
so pass me the water please so i can do my job better
goodluck scot glad you are here and i hope you are excited to get started as well.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 1:01 pm
by DEHog
Old School you would know more than me...I saw a few stories thought this was interesting. Also I'm wondering why he was not signed by someone last year?
He tried to deaden the pain by logging more hours, refusing to delegate. At Christmas, he watched his kids open presents, then left to go to the office, even though he had nothing to do. He ended up turning back home, but a dull guilt remained. When he was at work he should be at home; when he was at home he should be at work. And he kept drinking, which made him feel guiltiest of all. Work and life “became too much for him,” Kent says. His marriage started crumbling. Kelli, who declined to speak for this story, told Kent, “We have to do something.” Scot checked into a Betty Ford clinic, hoping to save his marriage. “It worked,” McCloughan says.
“For a whileThe next day he feels almost biologically compelled to work for a team, as if he owes it to his family and to his talent. His father, for one, wanted him to stay with an organization rather than run his own business. It’s a longing McCloughan struggles to articulate, which is probably why his farmhouse is livable but temporary. He wants to win another Super Bowl, and he wants to learn whether he can do so and still be his best self. The pressure, internal and external, is slowly creeping up. His name has been floated for expected openings in Oakland and elsewhere. Some scouts, eager to climb on board, have visited him in Ferndale for face time. McCloughan has mapped out potential hires for key positions, a support system of people who accept him, faults and all.
I don't see the Skins being or having a culture for this guy to be in....hope I'm wrong!!
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 1:03 pm
by Chris Luva Luva
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 1:06 pm
by DEHog
Chris Luva Luva wrote:
LOL Bruce sounded much better today...doing what he does best!!
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 1:11 pm
by emoses14
So if we are to believe Scot and Bruce, they've been discussing this GM move as early as beginning of 2014 season, and seemingly before the Allen press conference. Interesting. Also, apparently this is a guy (Scot) that they've (or at least Bruce) wanted and pursued hard once it was clear he wanted to come back to football.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 1:18 pm
by riggofan
This is kind of interesting...
Its a Big Man's Game
1. In looking around to read as much as I can on Scot McCloughan there is one point that comes up frequently—he like big guys. “I’ll never lose sight of this and maybe I’m a dinosaur in this, but it’s a big man’s game,” he said at the 2010 NFL Combine when he was the GM of the 49ers.
2. So, don’t look for the Redskins to draft that undersized but feisty linebacker or a small but high-motor defensive lineman. And you have to think that 295-lb. center Kory Lichtensteiger and 5-10, 178-lb. wide receiver DeSean Jackson may not have long futures with the team. As to the future of the latter player, John Keim of ESPN noted that McCloughan drafted eight receivers at San Francisco and all but one were at least six feet tall and five were 6-1 or taller. And if the Redskins stick with the 3-4 defense it’s hard not to be very pessimistic on the future of Barry Cofield, who is not the traditional big-body nose tackle that is usually in the middle of the line in that scheme.
3. However, it’s not a hard and fast rule. When they were evaluating 5-10 quarterback Russell Wilson before the 2012 draft, McCloughan wrote this in his report: “Obviously we are really interested in passers with better height, but this guy may just be the exception to the rule. He has the ‘it’ factor.” We saw how that pick turned out in last year’s Super Bowl.
Out: As noted here yesterday it is going to take a while for McCloughan to build the Redskins the way he wants to. It’s not just a matter of getting good players, it’s a matter of getting the right kind of good players (i.e. big players) and then giving them some time to develop.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 1:31 pm
by DEHog
As noted here yesterday it is going to take a while for McCloughan to build the Redskins the way he wants to. It’s not just a matter of getting good players, it’s a matter of getting the right kind of good players (i.e. big players) and then giving them some time to develop.
Maybe not he said the Redskins are > 9ers when he got there

Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 1:35 pm
by emoses14
DEHog wrote:As noted here yesterday it is going to take a while for McCloughan to build the Redskins the way he wants to. It’s not just a matter of getting good players, it’s a matter of getting the right kind of good players (i.e. big players) and then giving them some time to develop.
Maybe not he said the Redskins are > 9ers when he got there


really?
OK

Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 1:40 pm
by DEHog
I like that he said the DC choice was Jay's to make and that Jay would be in charge of hiring all his coaching staff.
Re: Scot McCloughan named new GM
Posted: Fri Jan 09, 2015 1:48 pm
by emoses14
Me too, DEHog. Then I fell in love with:
"I have final say [on 53 man roster]"